Clubman aftershave and bay rum are two of the most recognizable smells in a barbershop, and the quick answer to “should I splash it on?” is: it depends on your skin and how you shave. The sting is real, it comes mostly from the alcohol, and a balm is the gentler choice if your face gets irritated or bumpy after a shave. Below we explain what is actually in these bottles, where the names come from, and how to pick between a splash and a balm.
One honest note before we start. We could not find any source that ties Clubman or bay rum specifically to Black barbershops, so we will not call either one “the Black barbershop aftershave”. What we can say is that both are barbershop classics, and that the barbershop itself has a deep place in Black community life. That is the context this guide is written for.
Key Takeaways
- The brand says Pinaud was founded in France in 1810, but that is a brand claim, and independent accounts date Ed Pinaud’s own business later.[1]
- A retailer’s copy of the Clubman After Shave label lists SD Alcohol 40B first, followed by fragrance allergens including limonene, linalool, citral and geraniol.[2]
- In a small study of healthy volunteers, transepidermal water loss rose significantly after hair removal with a disposable razor, which points to a disrupted skin barrier.[3]
- A safety review found topical ethanol is associated with skin irritation or contact dermatitis.[4]
- If your skin is sensitive or prone to razor bumps, a balm is usually the kinder option, and clippers were linked to lower odds of bumps in one cohort.[5]
The Barbershop Is More Than a Place to Get a Cut
The Smithsonian’s National Museum of African American History and Culture describes barbershops and salons as serving a unique social function.[6] Anyone who grew up with a standing appointment knows what that means: it is where news gets argued over, advice gets passed down and a young man learns how to carry himself. The smell is part of the memory. Talc, hair oil, clipper oil and a splash of something sharp and citrusy on the neck.
That is the setting where products like Clubman and bay rum earned their reputations. They belong to the barbershop as a whole, which is why we describe them as shop classics rather than as belonging to any one community.
Pinaud and Clubman: The Story as the Brand Tells It
The maker says Pinaud was founded in France in 1810.[1] Treat that date as marketing: the same source notes that independent accounts place Ed Pinaud’s own business later. It is a good reminder that heritage dates on a bottle are a story the brand chooses to tell, not a verified timeline.
What the maker does say plainly is who Clubman is aimed at. It markets Clubman After Shave Lotion as the choice of barbers.[7] It also describes the scent as orange, bergamot and lemon top notes with green nuances.[7] That matches what most people recall: bright citrus up front, then a clean, slightly herbal finish. We are reporting the maker’s description here, not our own testing.
What Is Actually on the Label
Ingredient lists matter more than the heritage story. A retailer’s copy of the Clubman After Shave label lists SD Alcohol 40B first, followed by fragrance allergens including limonene, linalool, citral and geraniol.[2] Labels vary by retailer and by production run, so check the bottle in your hand rather than trusting any web listing, ours included.
Two things stand out. Alcohol first means ethanol is the main ingredient by amount, which is what gives a splash its quick-drying, cooling feel. And the allergen names are there because regulators require certain fragrance components to be listed. Their presence does not mean the product is unsafe for most people, only that a small share of people react to them. We cover that below.
Bay Rum: A Caribbean Story
Bay rum is a different thing from Clubman, even though they often share a shelf. The bay tree used for it is Pimenta racemosa, in the myrtle family.[8] It is native to low forest slopes of northern South America and the Caribbean.[9]
Traditionally, bay rum is made by steeping bay tree leaves in rum to extract the oil, often with lime and clove added.[9] The Virgin Islands have a particular claim here. According to the St. John Historical Society, bay oil from St. John was shipped to St. Thomas and made into bay rum there,[8] and Virgin Islands bay rum gained a reputation as the finest in the world.[8] A current bay rum maker says that the Danish Plantation Company bought 237 acres at Cinnamon Bay on St. John in 1903 to grow bay trees.[10] That last point is a maker’s account, so weigh it accordingly.
Be aware that many bottles sold as “bay rum” today are fragranced alcohol rather than a leaf-and-rum infusion. The label tells you which one you have. Look for the bay leaf oil or Pimenta racemosa in the ingredients, and for what the base liquid is.
Why the Splash Stings
Shaving is not gentle on skin even when it goes well. In a small study of healthy volunteers, transepidermal water loss rose significantly after hair removal with a disposable razor, and microlesions appeared, which indicates skin barrier disruption.[3] In that same study clipper use did not significantly change water loss.[3] Note that this was a small study on calf skin, not faces, and it comes from a lower-tier journal, so treat it as a pointer rather than a rule.
A second, better-regarded study looked at faces and necks. In ten healthy men, shortly after electric shaving of the forearm, cheek and neck, water loss rose significantly with increased blood flow, and the size of the change varied by site.[11] The good news is that most skin measures returned to baseline 24 hours after shaving, so the changes were transient.[11]
Now add ethanol. A safety review found topical ethanol is associated with skin irritation or contact dermatitis, especially in people with aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) deficiency.[4] The same review found that ethanol applied to skin can act as a penetration enhancer, so it may help other substances in a product absorb through the skin.[4] In an ex vivo pig-ear skin model, ethanol added to a cream raised water loss and lowered skin hydration on intact skin, consistent with barrier impairment.[12] That is a lab model on animal skin, not a trial on shaved human faces, but it fits with what many men feel.
Barrier damage also changes what gets through. In a study of healthy volunteers, salicylic acid dissolved in ethanol penetrated barrier-damaged forearm skin 2.2-fold more, and up to 157-fold more when tape-stripped, than normal skin.[13] The damage there came from acetone, detergent or tape rather than shaving, so it does not measure what happens after a shave. It simply shows how much a compromised barrier lets in, which is one reason to think twice about what you put on fresh-shaved skin.
We should be straight about what this does not prove. Nobody in this research tested Clubman or bay rum on shaved faces. The evidence is general: razors disturb the barrier, and ethanol can irritate and disrupt it. The sting you feel is consistent with that, but it is not a measurement of your skin.
Fragrance, Eugenol and Allergy
Some fragrance ingredients become stronger allergens once they meet air. A review of limonene says the pure compound rarely caused a positive patch test, but once exposed to air it forms hydroperoxides that are far stronger sensitizers.[14] A review of linalool says the same of its hydroperoxides, which have a far stronger sensitizing potency than pure linalool.[15] In North American patch testing, hydroperoxides of linalool were positive in 10.1% of patients, ranking fourth among all allergens, though those patients were referred for suspected contact dermatitis, so it is not a general-population rate.[16]
Bay rum brings its own allergen to the conversation. In a lab study, bay leaf oil from Pimenta racemosa killed house dust mites, with eugenol among the active compounds, though that says nothing about use on skin.[17] Eugenol is the main compound in clove oil, and a review states it is a primary irritant and sensitizer that can cause contact dermatitis and irritate skin, eyes and airways.[18] In a repeat open application test, four of five volunteers already sensitized to eugenol reacted to the maximum allowed eugenol level in a leave-on product over 4 weeks.[18] If clove-heavy scents have ever made your skin itch or flare, that is worth remembering when you shop for bay rum.
For context, a review states the prevalence of fragrance allergy in the general population is between 0.7% and 2.6%.[19] That is a minority, but the beard area is a well-known trouble spot: a 1969 case series documented 16 men over four years with perfume allergy from products used on the beard area before or after shaving.[20] Itching right after applying an aftershave is usually irritant contact dermatitis, though one case report found true contact urticaria caused by phenoxyethanol in the product.[21]
A word on darker skin. Review authors note that in higher Fitzpatrick skin types, positive patch tests often show lichenification and hyperpigmentation rather than redness and blisters, so reactions can be missed.[22] If a product leaves dark, rough or itchy patches rather than obvious redness, do not assume it is fine. Stop using it and, if it persists, see a dermatologist.
Razor Bumps and the Splash
Razor bumps (pseudofolliculitis barbae) are the bigger concern for many Black men. A review describes the condition as seen almost exclusively in Black men aged 14 to 25, with a prevalence between 45% and 83%.[23] Carriers of a keratin gene variant (A12T) have a six-fold greater chance of developing razor bumps.[23] Technique matters too: razor bumps can result from stretching the skin and using blades that pull the hair instead of cutting it, so the hair tip retracts below the skin surface.[23]
In a cohort of police students of African descent in Dakar, shaving against the grain carried an odds ratio of 6.3 for razor bumps,[5] a single-blade razor was linked to higher odds (odds ratio 2.5),[5] and clippers were protective (odds ratio 0.5).[5] Those are associations from one group, not guarantees. We have found no evidence that a splash prevents or treats razor bumps, and we would not claim it does. For a fuller routine, see our guide to razor bump treatment and prevention, and if clippers suit your face, our best clippers for Black men and best electric shavers for Black men lists are a good place to start.
What to Look For in a Clean Shop
A good shop is about more than the smell. Hygiene research on barbershops is limited, but a few findings tell you what to watch for. In a survey of randomly selected barbershops in Kumasi, Ghana, 46.5% of barbers used a UV sterilizer cabinet, 29% used 70% alcohol and 23% used antiseptic solutions to sterilize trimmers.[24] The same survey found that only 36.5% of barbers had heard of hepatitis B and 5% of hepatitis C, and none used a new apron or washed hands after each client.[24] That is one city in one year, so do not generalise it to any shop you walk into.
A newer, low-confidence preprint describes a cluster in Germany. After nine people got Trichophyton tonsurans ringworm from one barbershop, three of ten environmental samples were positive, including shaving equipment and the drawer that stored it.[25] A US paediatrics review also notes that viable ringworm spores can be cultured from contaminated combs, hairbrushes, barbershop instruments, shared hats, clothing and bedding.[26]
So what should you look for? Treat these as sensible habits drawn from the findings above, not a certified checklist:
- Clippers and trimmers that are cleaned or disinfected between clients, not just brushed off.
- A fresh neck strip or a clean cape for every client.
- Razor blades that are new or single-use for each shave, and a barber who washes hands between clients.
- Combs and brushes kept in a disinfectant rather than loose in a drawer.
- A barber who is happy to explain what they use. Good ones usually are.
And one more tip: the splash a barber puts on at the end is not a substitute for disinfecting tools. If a shop leans on the aftershave as its “clean” step, ask questions.
Splash or Balm: Who Should Pick What
Here is where we land, based on the evidence above and common sense.
A splash may suit you if your skin tolerates alcohol, you rarely get bumps or redness, and you value the scent and the ritual. Many men enjoy it. Keep it off any nicks or broken skin, since ethanol is associated with irritation,[4] and keep alcohol-based products away from open flame and away from children.
A balm is the smarter pick if your face stings, tightens or turns red after shaving, you get razor bumps, or you have a history of fragrance reactions. In a lab skin model, the inflammation and barrier damage matching a dry razor pass were reduced by applying shaving foam before, or moisturiser after.[27] That is a lab model, but it supports the idea that a good lubricant before and a moisturiser after are worth more than a sting. Our guides to the best aftershave for Black men and the best aftershave for sensitive skin cover balms in detail.
You can also split the difference: use a balm on your face and keep the bay rum or Clubman for the neckline after a clipper edge-up, where the skin tends to be less reactive. Patch test any new scent on a small area for a few days first. And if you simply love the smell, a fragrance worn as cologne on clothes or pulse points avoids putting alcohol on freshly shaved skin altogether.
How We Wrote This
This guide draws on peer-reviewed dermatology papers, a small number of laboratory and ex vivo studies, clinical reviews of fragrance allergy, a museum story, a local historical society, a botanical garden record, retailer label copy, and statements from the brands themselves. Maker statements are attributed as such and are not treated as fact. We did not test any product ourselves, and no source we found ties Clubman or bay rum to any particular community. This article is general information, not medical advice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Clubman aftershave alcohol-free?
No. A retailer’s copy of the Clubman After Shave label lists SD Alcohol 40B first.[2] Labels vary, so read the bottle you are buying.
Is bay rum made with real rum?
Traditionally, yes: bay rum is made by steeping bay tree leaves in rum, often with lime and clove added.[9] Many modern products use a different alcohol base and added fragrance, so check the ingredients.
Why does aftershave burn?
Shaving disturbs the skin barrier, and a safety review found topical ethanol is associated with skin irritation.[4] In a pig-ear skin model, ethanol raised water loss and lowered hydration.[12] The burn is consistent with that, though we cannot measure it on your face.
Will aftershave stop razor bumps?
We found no evidence that it will. Razor bump risk is linked to technique and hair type: shaving against the grain carried an odds ratio of 6.3 in one cohort.[5] See our razor bumps guide for what to change.
Can I be allergic to my aftershave?
Yes. A review states the prevalence of fragrance allergy in the general population is between 0.7% and 2.6%.[19] Eugenol, found in clove oil, is described as a primary irritant and sensitizer.[18] If a product causes itching, a rash or dark patches, stop using it.
References
- Clubman Pinaud History – The Official Barber Brand. Clubman Online (Pinaud-Clubman, American International Industries)
- Aftershave Lotion by Pinaud Clubman (ingredient list). Sally Beauty (retailer, copies label)
- Changes of the skin barrier and bacterial colonization after hair removal by clipper and by razor. Journal of Biomedical Photonics & Engineering, 2016
- Safety evaluation of topical applications of ethanol on the skin and inside the oral cavity. Journal of Occupational Medicine and Toxicology, 2008
- [Pseudofolliculitis barbae in police students in Dakar: epidemiological and clinical aspects, and associated risk factors]. Medecine tropicale et sante internationale, 2024
- The Community Roles of the Barber Shop and Beauty Salon. National Museum of African American History and Culture, Smithsonian
- Clubman After Shave Lotion, 6 oz. Clubman Online (Pinaud-Clubman)
- Bay Rum: A Niche of Distinction in VI History. St. John Historical Society (Gail Schulterbrandt), 2005
- Pimenta racemosa (Plant Finder). Missouri Botanical Garden
- History of St Johns Bay Rum Brand. St Johns Fragrance Company (St Johns Bay Rum)
- An exploratory study of structural and microvascular changes in the skin following electrical shaving using optical coherence topography. Skin research and technology : official journal of International Society for Bioengineering and the Skin (ISBS) [and] International Society for Digital Imaging of Skin (ISDIS) [and] International Society for Skin Imaging (ISSI), 2024
- Influence of Ethanol as a Preservative in Topical Formulation on the Dermal Penetration Efficacy of Active Compounds in Healthy and Barrier-Disrupted Skin. Pharmaceutics, 2025
- Effect of barrier perturbation on cutaneous salicylic acid penetration in human skin: in vivo pharmacokinetics using microdialysis and non-invasive quantification of barrier function. The British journal of dermatology, 1999
- Limonene Hydroperoxides. Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug, 2019
- Linalool Hydroperoxides. Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug, 2019
- North American Contact Dermatitis Group Patch Test Results: 2021-2022. Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug, 2025
- Acaricidal activity of identified constituents from Pimenta racemosa and Cymbopogon martini essential oils toward Dermatophagoides farinae. 세계곤충학회(ICE2012)1주년 기념 공동 심포지엄 및 2013 추계학술발표회, 2013
- Eugenol: From the Remote Maluku Islands to the International Market Place: A Review of a Remarkable and Versatile Molecule. Molecules, 2012
- Allergic Contact Dermatitis to Fragrances. Dermatologic clinics, 2020
- Perfume dermatitis in men. PubMed, 1969
- Contact urticaria due to phenoxyethanol in an aftershave. Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug, 2009
- Allergic Contact Dermatitis and Patch Testing in Skin of Color Patients. Dermatitis : contact, atopic, occupational, drug, 2023
- Dermatology in black skin. Anais Brasileiros de Dermatologia, 2024
- Knowledge and occupational hazards of barbers in the transmission of hepatitis B and C was low in Kumasi, Ghana. The Pan African medical journal, 2015
- Trichophyton tonsurans infections after visiting a barbershop – findings from official hygiene monitoring. PubMed Central, 2024
- Tinea Corporis and Tinea Capitis. Pediatrics in Review, 2007
- Development of a novel in vitro strategy to understand the impact of shaving on skin health: combining tape strip exfoliation and human skin equivalent technology. Frontiers in medicine, 2023

